Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025: Islanders Make Bold Move with No. 1 Overall Pick

Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025

Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025: Islanders Make Emotional No. 1 Pick

The Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025 story is more than just a tale of elite talent—it’s a journey marked by resilience, heartbreak, and triumph. On Friday night, the New York Islanders selected defenseman Matthew Schaefer with the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, held at the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles. It was a historic and emotional moment, not just for the franchise, but for a young man who has endured unimaginable loss on his path to hockey greatness.

A Poised Pick: Why the Islanders Chose Matthew Schaefer

With the top selection in the Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025, the Islanders chose a player who not only ranks among the top defensive prospects of the decade but also embodies mental toughness and leadership.

Schaefer, a 6-foot-2 blueliner from Hamilton, Ontario, played the last two seasons with the OHL’s Erie Otters. Despite missing much of the 2024–25 season due to a collarbone injury, he posted 22 points in just 17 games—a testament to his two-way game and offensive instincts.

Known for his elite skating, transition play, and defensive reads, Schaefer has long been on the radar of NHL scouts. His ability to quarterback a power play and shut down rushes makes him a rare, complete package.

“He’s an unbelievable hockey player,” Islanders GM Mathieu Darche said. “His poise, maturity, and resilience—especially after everything he’s been through—make him one of the most impressive young men I’ve ever met.”

Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025: A Tribute to His Late Mother

Perhaps the most touching moment of the Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025 was the tribute he paid to his late mother, Jennifer, who passed away from breast cancer in early 2024. As Schaefer walked on stage wearing the Islanders’ jersey with a purple Hockey Fights Cancer ribbon stitched on it, he kissed the patch and broke down in tears.

The Islanders added the ribbon and embroidered his mother’s initials “J.S.” on his jersey—an emotional gesture that moved Schaefer and viewers across the globe.

“Seeing the ribbon on my jersey and her initials—it means the world to me,” Schaefer said. “My mom’s not here physically, but she’s with me every step of the way. This organization has already shown they care beyond the game.”

Inside his suit, a photo and signature of his mom were stitched over his heart. “I know she has the best seat in the house tonight,” Schaefer added. “I miss her so much.”

The Human Behind the Talent

At just 17 years old, Schaefer has dealt with more loss than most people face in a lifetime. In addition to his mother, he also lost Emily Matson, his billet mom, and Jim Waters, the owner of the Erie Otters—all in the past 18 months.

His emotional strength, combined with his on-ice brilliance, was a significant factor in the Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025 spotlight.

“It’s more than hockey,” said Darche. “We saw a leader, a fighter, someone who plays with purpose. That’s the kind of player we want in our locker room.”

Historical Significance of the Pick

Matthew Schaefer became just the fifth defenseman selected No. 1 overall since 2000, joining names like Owen Power and Erik Johnson. He also became only the second player from the Erie Otters to be drafted first overall—the first being Connor McDavid in 2015.

For the Islanders, this marked their first No. 1 overall pick since 2009, making the Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025 decision not just symbolic but potentially franchise-altering.

Draft Night Drama and Strategic Moves

While Schaefer’s selection at No. 1 was expected by many, the Islanders made several bold moves throughout the night. They also drafted Swedish forward Victor Eklund at No. 16 and defenseman Kashawn Aitcheson at No. 17, rounding out a high-impact first round.

Meanwhile, other notable picks included:

• Michael Misa to the San Jose Sharks at No. 2
• Anton Frondell to the Chicago Blackhawks at No. 3
• James Hagens to the Boston Bruins at No. 7, another top prospect
• Caleb Desnoyers, who went No. 4 to the Utah Mammoth

Each selection made the 2025 NHL Draft one of the most exciting in recent memory.

What’s Next for Matthew Schaefer?

While expectations are high, the Islanders front office has made it clear: they won’t rush their top prospect.

“There’s no pressure on Matthew to play right away,” said Darche. “He’ll attend development camp, train, and we’ll assess what’s best for his growth.”

Still, fans are already buzzing about his NHL debut. With the Islanders looking to rebuild and Schaefer offering a rare blend of maturity and skill, many believe his impact could be felt sooner than later.

Legacy, Loss, and Leadership

The Matthew Schaefer NHL Draft 2025 experience will be remembered not just for his selection but for the meaning behind it. It was a reminder that behind every jersey is a human story—one of family, love, loss, and perseverance.

“I want to make her proud,” Schaefer said of his mother. “Everything I do is for her. And now, it’s for the Islanders too.”

With unmatched composure, a heart full of memory, and a stick ready to make history, Matthew Schaefer is more than a No. 1 pick—he’s a symbol of what it truly means to rise.

Read more: Hagens NHL Draft 2025